The Ugly Truth about Diamonds Monopoly

The word monopoly has its roots in the Greek words monos (single) and polein (to sell). It first appeared in Aristotle’s Politics, where Aristotle describes how in Greece in the 6th century BC the philosopher Thales of Miletus cornered the local olive press market:

Thales, so the story goes, because of his poverty was taunted with the uselessness of philosophy; but from his knowledge of astronomy he had observed while it was still winter that there was going to be a large crop of olives, so he raised a small sum of money and paid round deposits for the whole of the olive-presses in Miletus and Chios, which he hired at a low rent as nobody was running him up; and when the season arrived, there was a sudden demand for a number of presses at the same time, and by letting them out on what terms he liked he realized a large sum of money, so proving that it is easy for philosophers to be rich if they choose.

Historically one of the most interesting and controversial monopolies is arguably that of the diamond market in recent times.

Throughout history the supply of diamonds has been very scarce. So much so that it was very difficult even for the creme de la creme of society to get hold of these little stones.

The History of De Beers

Things, however, started to change in the late 19th century when diamonds were found in South Africa and a lot of supply suddenly flooded the market. The price of what had been valuable only because of its scarcity was bound to fall. To prevent that taking place, in 1888 a cartel with all the movers and shakers of the diamond mining world was formed under the name De Beers, and oh, what a cartel it has proved to be.

Once the supply of the diamonds was under their control, they also had to take care of the other side of the equation – the demand.

To do this they joined forces with an advertising agency, N. W. Ayer & Son to impact “social attitudes of the public at large and thereby channel American spending toward larger and more expensive diamonds instead of ‘competitive luxuries'”, as they put it.

The Control of the Diamond Market

To prevent any price fluctuations caused by selling the diamonds, they had to convince the masses to hold onto them, and not to “trade”. This is where the motto “diamonds are forever” was born. With a sophisticated advertising and PR campaign they turned diamonds into epitomes of eternal romance and love. In the next few decades sales of diamonds in the US increased a hundredfold. Not bad, right?

However, it didn’t end there. They then proceeded to expand to other global markets. In Japan they literally turned a 1,500 year old Japanese marriage tradition upside down as the number of men giving diamond engagement rings to their women rapidly increased in a mere 14 years. Let me tell you, changing Japanese cultural norms is no small task and yet today Japanese men purchase diamonds for their brides as readily as Americans or Europeans.

Whenever a new diamond deposit was discovered in the world De Beers rushed in and bought it to minimize fluctuations in diamond prices. They had been relatively successful at that until the very end of the 20th century. At the turn of the century some of the diamond producer countries decided to bypass De Beers’ distribution channels and alternatives have hit the market.

Synthetic and Real Diamonds are Indistinguishable

Determining the validity of a diamond takes an expert, and these days even the experts struggle to tell an artificial diamond from a natural one. The average man on the street hasn’t a hope in Hell of knowing the difference.

There are two alternatives to diamonds I’m aware of: moissanite and cubic zirconia, and neither of them have defects, which incidentally is one means of identifying fake from real diamonds. Synthetic diamonds have also been created in labs for decades now and these diamonds are indistinguishable from real diamonds because they are in fact diamonds. They are also produced at an absolute fraction of the price of real diamonds.

Diamonds aren’t Rare – They’re Common

For anyone who does a little research you’ll find that diamonds are clearly not rare. Certain diamonds, such as graded diamonds are somewhat rare, but diamonds themselves are certainly not rare. Even if we pretended for a minute that yes, diamonds are rare, we’re faced with the problem that artificial diamonds can be created by the boatload for next to nothing.

Diamonds are not liquid either. Try selling a diamond back to a jeweler and you’ll find that typically jewelers will pay between 75% and 80% of the purchase price if the diamond wasn’t bought from the store and is verifiable. In fact many jewelers won’t buy a diamond back unless you’ve previously purchased that same diamond from them and have the documentation to prove it. Even then they’ll typically only do a trade in, whereby you buy another higher priced diamond and trade your old diamond in.

In my book then diamonds are a terrible investment. Not rare, not liquid and not valuable.

That’s my opinion which is clearly not shared by the world at large. It’s the perception of rarity that matters. Not unlike the perception of safety afforded JGBs, US Treasury bonds, and EU bonds, people value these assets because they are perceived to be valuable. They’re not, but that’s beside the point….until well…until it isn’t.

Clever Marketing That Created A False Demand

How come people buy Rolex watches when many of the fake versions today are indistinguishable from the real ones and, according to a number of jewellers, function just as well? Why do people buy Coca Cola, paying more than any number of the cola versions out there which cost less and have the same amount of disgusting ingredients? How is it that diamonds, which are not rare, and which can be produced for a fraction of the cost, sell for such ridiculous prices?

The answer seems to be that the con job pulled off by arguably THE most successful marketing campaign in corporate history lives on. 15 years ago De Beers controlled about 80% of the market but that figure has now fallen below 40%. I’m simply surprised that their hold on the market has lasted as long as it has. An exceptional feat. Well done chaps.

A good friend of mine who is a successful real estate agent likes to say that the key to a sale is ensuring that the woman is pulled over the line. A man will rarely buy a home his wife doesn’t like. I think the same is probably true of diamonds. Try telling your fiance that you bought her a synthetic diamond engagement ring and, “Oh, honey aren’t you glad I saved a couple of grand?” See how well that goes down.

– Chris

“A diamond is forever.” – N.W. Ayer & Son Agency


This Post Has 3 Comments

    1. Chris MacIntosh

      I really don’t know enough to make a qualified judgement. If I was to make a guess (because that’s what it is) I’d say that in the next few decades the allure of diamonds will wane. Since companies like gemesis don’t have any real barrier to entry there is little scale opportunity. I like businesses which can scale rapidly

Leave a Reply